Righteous Invasion of Cringe: I Survived 90s Christian Music
Righteous Invasion Of Turd
I need to explain the particular flavor of Christian upbringing I came out of, because it wasn’t just one thing. It was two, and they didn’t always agree.
My mom, for all that she was strict in a lot of ways, also had this weird countercurrent running through her. She was a product of the hippie era, and she never fully let go of that. She took me to see Jurassic Park when I was a kid, which in some Christian households would have been considered questionable at best. She listened to the music she grew up with and didn’t apologize for it. In 1994, she took me to New York to see The Eagles on their Hell Freezes Over tour, and I got Don Henley’s autograph. That is one of the very few genuinely good memories I have of her.
And I hold onto that, because the rest is complicated. My mom was physically, verbally, and sexually abusive. She swung wildly between being overly strict and completely neglectful, sometimes in the same day. So even the freedom she gave me didn’t always feel stable. It felt arbitrary. Conditional. Like the rules could change at any moment.
At the same time, there was another influence in my life that was much more rigid and consistent. I spent a lot of my formative years in Maine with my Pentecostal grandparents and my uncle Chris (who was born late, was the same age as my brother, and became a youth pastor), and they were firmly in the “no secular anything” camp. No secular music. No secular TV outside of news programs. No going to the movies at all. Not “be careful,” not “use discernment.” Just no.
So I was growing up inside two overlapping systems. One said, “This is dangerous, but you can engage with it sometimes.” The other said, “This is dangerous, full stop, and you should not touch it at all.”
And then there was church.
My youth pastor lived somewhere in between. He listened to secular music, but he very clearly encouraged us toward Christian music. That was the safer option. The approved option. The one that wouldn’t get you side-eyed in a small group discussion. He took us to Christian concerts, to festivals like Creation, and even out of state to see DC Talk and Audio Adrenaline.
And to be fair to my mom, she didn’t really care if I listened to something like Pearl Jam. That was fine. But there were lines you did not cross. Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson were absolutely over those lines. Which of course meant I was going to listen to them anyway. At one point I snuck out to see Nine Inch Nails with Marilyn Manson opening, telling her I was going to Bible study. When I went to Woodstock ’99, I told her I was going to a Christian concert.
The end result of all of this was that I ended up in a strange middle space. I was exposed to CCM because that was what my church and youth group pushed, but I also had enough exposure to secular music to know what it actually sounded like when a genre was done well, or at least done authentically.
And that’s where something started to click for me, even if I didn’t have the language for it yet. I could hear, pretty clearly, that a lot of what I was being told was a “holy alternative” was actually just borrowing heavily from the very “worldly” music we were warned against. The same sounds, the same structures, the same trends—just repackaged, toned down, and relabeled as safe. There was this constant message that secular music was dangerous, corrupt, something to be avoided… and yet the music we were supposed to listen to kept chasing it, copying it, trailing behind it by years.
Even as a kid, that disconnect felt weird. Not just musically, but philosophically. If the outside world was so bad, why did everything inside our bubble sound like a slightly delayed echo of it?
And a really terrible one at that. Even when I was still Christian, I loathed most of the music I was "supposed" to listen to.
My mom, for all that she was strict in a lot of ways, also had this weird countercurrent running through her. She was a product of the hippie era, and she never fully let go of that. She took me to see Jurassic Park when I was a kid, which in some Christian households would have been considered questionable at best. She listened to the music she grew up with and didn’t apologize for it. In 1994, she took me to New York to see The Eagles on their Hell Freezes Over tour, and I got Don Henley’s autograph. That is one of the very few genuinely good memories I have of her.
And I hold onto that, because the rest is complicated. My mom was physically, verbally, and sexually abusive. She swung wildly between being overly strict and completely neglectful, sometimes in the same day. So even the freedom she gave me didn’t always feel stable. It felt arbitrary. Conditional. Like the rules could change at any moment.
At the same time, there was another influence in my life that was much more rigid and consistent. I spent a lot of my formative years in Maine with my Pentecostal grandparents and my uncle Chris (who was born late, was the same age as my brother, and became a youth pastor), and they were firmly in the “no secular anything” camp. No secular music. No secular TV outside of news programs. No going to the movies at all. Not “be careful,” not “use discernment.” Just no.
So I was growing up inside two overlapping systems. One said, “This is dangerous, but you can engage with it sometimes.” The other said, “This is dangerous, full stop, and you should not touch it at all.”
And then there was church.
My youth pastor lived somewhere in between. He listened to secular music, but he very clearly encouraged us toward Christian music. That was the safer option. The approved option. The one that wouldn’t get you side-eyed in a small group discussion. He took us to Christian concerts, to festivals like Creation, and even out of state to see DC Talk and Audio Adrenaline.
And to be fair to my mom, she didn’t really care if I listened to something like Pearl Jam. That was fine. But there were lines you did not cross. Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson were absolutely over those lines. Which of course meant I was going to listen to them anyway. At one point I snuck out to see Nine Inch Nails with Marilyn Manson opening, telling her I was going to Bible study. When I went to Woodstock ’99, I told her I was going to a Christian concert.
The end result of all of this was that I ended up in a strange middle space. I was exposed to CCM because that was what my church and youth group pushed, but I also had enough exposure to secular music to know what it actually sounded like when a genre was done well, or at least done authentically.
And that’s where something started to click for me, even if I didn’t have the language for it yet. I could hear, pretty clearly, that a lot of what I was being told was a “holy alternative” was actually just borrowing heavily from the very “worldly” music we were warned against. The same sounds, the same structures, the same trends—just repackaged, toned down, and relabeled as safe. There was this constant message that secular music was dangerous, corrupt, something to be avoided… and yet the music we were supposed to listen to kept chasing it, copying it, trailing behind it by years.
Even as a kid, that disconnect felt weird. Not just musically, but philosophically. If the outside world was so bad, why did everything inside our bubble sound like a slightly delayed echo of it?
And a really terrible one at that. Even when I was still Christian, I loathed most of the music I was "supposed" to listen to.
My Top 10 Hall of Shame
10. Petra - "Beyond Belief"
This shit sounds like someone tried to reverse-engineer Styx and Journey well over a decade after either band had peaked. It’s not just that it sounds dated. It sounds like a memory of a sound, reconstructed from vibes and a moral obligation.
This shit sounds like someone tried to reverse-engineer Styx and Journey well over a decade after either band had peaked. It’s not just that it sounds dated. It sounds like a memory of a sound, reconstructed from vibes and a moral obligation.
9. Newsboys - "Shine"
One of the most obnoxious songs I have ever heard in my life. It is aggressively peppy, aggressively inescapable, and yes, it contains that lyric about "Eskimos renouncing fur" (colonialism much?) and vegans barbecuing hamster, which was my introduction to a particularly batshit strain of fundamentalism imported from Australia. What in the actual fuck.
One of the most obnoxious songs I have ever heard in my life. It is aggressively peppy, aggressively inescapable, and yes, it contains that lyric about "Eskimos renouncing fur" (colonialism much?) and vegans barbecuing hamster, which was my introduction to a particularly batshit strain of fundamentalism imported from Australia. What in the actual fuck.
8. Rebecca St. James - "God" tied with "You're the Voice"
Speaking of Australia, we have Rebecca St. James with “God” and her cover of “You’re the Voice.” A girl in my youth group once told me she liked Rebecca St. James because “she sounds like Alanis Morissette.” Which is technically true in the same way that a store-brand soda “tastes like Coke.” This was the musical equivalent of the “I want to listen to Alanis” / “we have Alanis at home” meme. All the shape of rebellion, none of the actual bite.
Speaking of Australia, we have Rebecca St. James with “God” and her cover of “You’re the Voice.” A girl in my youth group once told me she liked Rebecca St. James because “she sounds like Alanis Morissette.” Which is technically true in the same way that a store-brand soda “tastes like Coke.” This was the musical equivalent of the “I want to listen to Alanis” / “we have Alanis at home” meme. All the shape of rebellion, none of the actual bite.
7. "Jesus Is Just Alright" tied with "Just Between You and Me" - DC Talk
How do you even begin to describe DC Talk?
On the one hand, you have their early phase: two extremely white guys with a token Black dude doing hip-hop so awkward it makes Vanilla Ice and Marky Mark look like gangstas. On the other hand, you have their later reinvention as generic 90s alt-rock (think: Dishwalla, Tonic, Duncan Sheik), which was somehow even worse, because at least the earlier stuff had the decency to be memorably bad.
How do you even begin to describe DC Talk?
On the one hand, you have their early phase: two extremely white guys with a token Black dude doing hip-hop so awkward it makes Vanilla Ice and Marky Mark look like gangstas. On the other hand, you have their later reinvention as generic 90s alt-rock (think: Dishwalla, Tonic, Duncan Sheik), which was somehow even worse, because at least the earlier stuff had the decency to be memorably bad.
6. "We're A Band" - Audio Adrenaline
My youth group, for reasons I will never fully understand, was EXTREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEMELY into Audio Adrenaline. As mentioned above, we went to see them in concert. We also saw DC Talk. And the best way I can describe Audio Adrenaline is this: imagine an early version of rap metal, but somehow stripped of anything that might make rap metal interesting, risky, or even slightly dangerous. What you’re left with is something aggressively wholesome and aggressively cringe.
My youth group, for reasons I will never fully understand, was EXTREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEMELY into Audio Adrenaline. As mentioned above, we went to see them in concert. We also saw DC Talk. And the best way I can describe Audio Adrenaline is this: imagine an early version of rap metal, but somehow stripped of anything that might make rap metal interesting, risky, or even slightly dangerous. What you’re left with is something aggressively wholesome and aggressively cringe.
5. "Cross of Gold" - Michael W. Smith
Admittedly, this song is a guilty pleasure. (Also the guitarist in this video is hot.) But it musically rips off "Turn It On Again" by Genesis so shamelessly I have included the Genesis song here for reference. I'm honestly surprised Mike didn't get sued.
The other really cringe thing about this song is that it's assmad at people who wear crosses strictly for aesthetic reasons. Even back in the early 90s when this song came out, America was a Christian-majority nation and still is. Pretty much anyone wearing a cross is aware of the spiritual context behind it and yes, is proclaiming their faith in Jesus Christ.
Admittedly, this song is a guilty pleasure. (Also the guitarist in this video is hot.) But it musically rips off "Turn It On Again" by Genesis so shamelessly I have included the Genesis song here for reference. I'm honestly surprised Mike didn't get sued.
The other really cringe thing about this song is that it's assmad at people who wear crosses strictly for aesthetic reasons. Even back in the early 90s when this song came out, America was a Christian-majority nation and still is. Pretty much anyone wearing a cross is aware of the spiritual context behind it and yes, is proclaiming their faith in Jesus Christ.
4. Pretty much everything ever by Stryper
Just… Stryper. And I say this as someone who actually loves hair metal. There is a version of this genre that works. This is not that version.
Also, I cannot fuck with any band that looks like Ted Cruz was in it.
Just… Stryper. And I say this as someone who actually loves hair metal. There is a version of this genre that works. This is not that version.
Also, I cannot fuck with any band that looks like Ted Cruz was in it.
|
|
3. Everything ever by Creed
Creed somehow managed to become mainstream, and still drove me absolutely up the wall. It’s not even just the music, although the music doesn’t help. It’s the whole package: the overblown, pseudo-profound lyrics that sound like they’re trying to say something deep without actually saying anything, the self-serious delivery, and that voice. That voice. Scott Stapp sings like Great Value Eddie Vedder permanently in the middle of a dramatic altar call, and every song feels like it’s one step away from turning into a sermon. It’s the same energy as CCM, just with a bigger budget and better marketing, and somehow that makes it more irritating, not less.
Bonus points for the fact that Stapp’s real-life behavior over the years has been… messy, to put it mildly, with a sex tape, very public struggles, legal issues, and erratic incidents that only made that whole hyper-serious persona feel even more hollow in retrospect.
Creed somehow managed to become mainstream, and still drove me absolutely up the wall. It’s not even just the music, although the music doesn’t help. It’s the whole package: the overblown, pseudo-profound lyrics that sound like they’re trying to say something deep without actually saying anything, the self-serious delivery, and that voice. That voice. Scott Stapp sings like Great Value Eddie Vedder permanently in the middle of a dramatic altar call, and every song feels like it’s one step away from turning into a sermon. It’s the same energy as CCM, just with a bigger budget and better marketing, and somehow that makes it more irritating, not less.
Bonus points for the fact that Stapp’s real-life behavior over the years has been… messy, to put it mildly, with a sex tape, very public struggles, legal issues, and erratic incidents that only made that whole hyper-serious persona feel even more hollow in retrospect.
2. Everything ever by Carman but ESPECIALLY "RIOT", "Addicted To Jesus" and "America Again"
Dear fucking G-d, Carman.
Carman gave us “Righteous Invasion of Truth,” or RIOT, which is such a blatant ripoff of "Rhythm Nation" that it’s almost impressive. And again, years after “Rhythm Nation” had already come and gone. He also had a fondness for Extremely White People Hip-Hop and for songs like “America Again,” which were less music and more culture war sermons set to a beat, complete with denunciations of homosexuality and anything else outside the approved moral framework. It was MAGA before MAGA, basically.
Dear fucking G-d, Carman.
Carman gave us “Righteous Invasion of Truth,” or RIOT, which is such a blatant ripoff of "Rhythm Nation" that it’s almost impressive. And again, years after “Rhythm Nation” had already come and gone. He also had a fondness for Extremely White People Hip-Hop and for songs like “America Again,” which were less music and more culture war sermons set to a beat, complete with denunciations of homosexuality and anything else outside the approved moral framework. It was MAGA before MAGA, basically.
1. "Fact and Reality" - The Brothers
At the absolute bottom of the barrel is The Brothers and their album Fact and Reality, which is the worst Christian music I have ever heard in my life, and I have heard a lot of bad Christian music, including Carman’s entire catalog. This is the kind of thing that makes you question not just your taste, but your life choices and the validity of Christianity itself.
At the absolute bottom of the barrel is The Brothers and their album Fact and Reality, which is the worst Christian music I have ever heard in my life, and I have heard a lot of bad Christian music, including Carman’s entire catalog. This is the kind of thing that makes you question not just your taste, but your life choices and the validity of Christianity itself.
One of the things I’ve observed quietly since becoming Jewish, is that there really isn’t an equivalent to CCM in non-Orthodox Jewish culture.
That’s not to say there isn’t Jewish music. There absolutely is. There are artists who are explicitly Jewish in their themes or identity, like Matisyahu or Kosha Dillz. There are artists who draw deeply from Jewish musical traditions, like Ofra Haza z"l whose work brought Yemeni Jewish sounds to a global audience. You have groups like Yamma Ensemble performing Sephardic and Mizrahi music like “Konja mia,” preserving and reinterpreting traditions that go back centuries.
But that’s not the same thing as a parallel entertainment industry designed to replace the mainstream.
When you ask me, off the top of my head, to name “Jewish music,” my brain doesn’t go to a closed system. It goes to people like David Draiman of Disturbed, The Beastie Boys, Barbra Streisand, Lenny Kravitz, and... Michael Bolton. Artists who happen to be Jewish, whose identity may inform their work in subtle or occasional ways, but who are fully part of the broader cultural landscape. They’re not trying to be a “safe alternative” to anything. They’re just making music.
Which is perfectly fine with me.
Because what CCM represents, at its core, is not just a genre. It’s a system of control. It’s what happens when a community decides that engagement with the outside world is dangerous, and instead of teaching people how to navigate that world, it tries to replace it wholesale with something “approved.” You don’t just get different lyrics. You get an entire parallel culture that is always slightly behind, slightly off, very weird, very fake, and constantly policing itself.
Non-Orthodox Jewish culture, for all its arguments and contradictions and internal diversity, doesn’t generally do that. There’s no expectation that you wall yourself off from broader art, music, or culture and consume only the “Jewish version” of things. If anything, Jewish culture has historically thrived on interaction, adaptation, and participation. We argue with the world. We borrow from it. We contribute to it. We don’t build a sealed-off imitation of it and pretend that’s somehow more authentic.
And after growing up in a system that tried very hard to do exactly that, I can’t overstate how much of a relief that is.
© Finleigh (FlameAndSong), 2026.
If you like this essay you may share the link.
If you like this essay you may share the link.
